Document Type: Original Articles

Authors

colleague of fars cochlear implant center

Abstract

Background: Reading is known as one of the most important learning tools. Research results consistently have shown that even a mild hearing impairment could affect the reading skills. Due to the reported differences in reading comprehension skills between hearing impaired students and their normal hearing peers, this research was conducted to compare the differences between the two groups. The other aim was to find any changes in the reading ability of hearing impaired group during elementary school.    Methods: This study is a cross-sectional (descriptive–analytic) one in which reading comprehension ability of 91 students with severe and profound hearing impairment ( 33 girls and 58 boys ) from 2nd  up to 5th grade of exceptional schools were compared with 50 2nd grade normal hearing students in Ahvaz, Iran. The first section of Diagnostic Reading Test (Shirazi – Nilipour, 2004) was used in this study. Then the mean reading scores of hearing impaired students in each grade was compared with control group using SPSS 13 with Mann Whitney test.Results: There was a significant difference between average scores of hearing impaired students (boys and girls) in  2nd  to 5th grade with normal hearing students of 2nd grade (P<0.001). Reading comprehension scores of students with hearing impairment in higher grades had improved slightly, but it was still lower than that of the normal hearing students in the 2nd grade.Conclusion: It appears that reading comprehension skill of students with significant hearing impairment near the end of elementary school years becomes weaker than normal hearing students in the second grade. Therefore, it is essential to find and resolve the underlying reasons of this condition by all professionals who work in the field of education and rehabilitation of these students.  

Keywords

  1. Shirazi TS, Nilipoor R. Developing & Standardization of a Diagnostic Reading Test .J of Rehabilitation: 2004; 5:7-11.
  2. Colin H. Understanding Reading Development.London: SAGE Publication Ltd; 2004.pp.1-25.
  3. Sharifi A, Kakojoibari A,Sarmadi M.Comparison of different levels of reading comprehension between hearing-impaired and normal-hearing students.Audiol:2010;19(2):25-32.
  4. Perfetti, C. A., & Sandak, R. Reading optimally builds on spoken language: applications for deaf readers. Journal of Deaf Studies and Deaf Education: 2000; 5, 32–50.
  5. Musselman, C. How do children who can’t hear learn to read an alphabetic script? A review of the literature on reading and deafness. Journal of Deaf Studies and Deaf Education: 2000; 5, 9–31.
  6. Cain k,Oakhill J. Children` s Comprehension Problems in Oral & Written Language: A Cognitive Perspective.1st ed. Guilford Press;2008,224-281.
  7. Kyle FE, Harris M. Predictors of reading development in deaf children: A 3-year longitudinal study. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology: 2010; 107: 229-243.
  8. Kakojoibari A, Sarmadi M, Sharifi A. Comparison of reading literacy in hearing impaired and normal hearing students. Audiol: 2010;19 (1):23-30.
  9. Kakojoibari A, Sharifi A.Hearing impaired students reading skills in exceptional and ordinary schools.Audiol;2012(4):44-50.
  10. Rezaei M ,Rashedi V , Tehrani L .Investigation and Comparison of Fifth Grade Elementary Student’s Reading Skills with Severe Hearing Loss and Hearing in Tehran, J of Rehabilitation : 2013;14(1):17-22.
  11. Mokhlesin M,Kasbi F, Ahadi H, Sojoudi F.Phonological awareness, working memory and reading comprehension in deaf children. Koomesh :2015; 16 (2):128-135.
  12. Nikkhou F, Hasanzadeh S, Afrooz GH. The comparative study of reading comprehension in normal hearing and hearing-loss student.Audiol:2012;21(2):71-77.
  13. Sharifi A ,Kakojoibari A, Sarmadi M,.Comparison of different levels of reading comprehension between hearing impaired and normal hearing students. Audiol: 2010;19(2):25-32.
  14. Harris M, Moreno C. Deaf children’s use of phonological coding: Evidence from reading, spelling, and working memory. J Deaf Stud Deaf Educ: 2004;(9): 253-268.
  15. MacSweeney M, Campbell R, Donlan C. Varieties of short-term memory coding in deaf teenagers. J Deaf Stud Deaf Educ: 1996;(1): 249-262.
  16. Rezaei M, Rashedi V, Gholami Tehrani L, Daroei A. Comparison of reading comprehension and working memory in hearing-impaired and normal-hearing children. Audiology:2013;(22): 67-74.
  17. Koo D, Crain K, LaSasso C, Eden GF. Phonological awareness and short-term memory in hearing and deaf individuals of different communication backgrounds. Ann N Y Acad Sci: 2008;(1145): 83-99.
  18. Mayberry RI, Del Giudice AA, Lieberman AM. Reading achievement in relation to phonological coding and awareness in deaf readers: A meta-analysis. J Deaf Stud Deaf Educ: 2011; (16): 164-188.